Covers. Hate it or love it. Since dawn of man (read: music), people have been playing, interpreting, reinventing, stealing and raping songs written by other people. It's in our spines. It's a part of our reptile behavior. In one way, covering other people songs is connected to one of the few really great lightbulb-jokes there is;
- How many guitarists does it take to change a lightbulb?
- Dunno.
- Twelve. One to change it, eleven to say that they could have done it better.
Isn't that just great? We all want to be the best, and it seems like one way to prove it is trying to improve other peoples songs.
In this question, I really don't know where to stand. I guess that I've developed a sort of love-hate towards covers over the years. On one hand, I associate covers with after ski and really, really bad band names ("T
he Grabbarna", "A
jrån Mejden"). But on the other hand, I've heard cover versions of songs that actually are better than the original. One of
Jimi Hendrix's greatest hits,
All along the watchtower, was originally written and played by
Bob Dylan, who after hearing the cover version of it refused to ever play it again. On the Swedish band
The Knife's second album
Deep Cuts, a song named
Heartbeats is included. Later on, the same song was
covered by, the also Swedish, artist José González, which gave him an international breakthrough thanks to playtime in the O.C. and the use of the song in the phenomenal commercial for Sony Bravia, seen in the link above. In the 1960's (oh, the sweet 60's) there were barely any bands who didn't have songs like
Money (
originally recorded by Barrett Strong) or
Roll over Beethoven (
originally recorded by Chuck Berry)
on their set lists, some versions better than others, and I don't know anyone who's concerned about this matter. Strange.
When it comes to me, I enjoy covers where the artist takes a song and totally reinvents it to fit with their own vision. There are only a handful examples of this sort of mutation that is worth looking up, but here beneath follows my Top 5 list of epic covers (
Hearbeats and
All along the watchtower excluded) followed by short comments:
- Life on Mars - Seu Jorge (this song is featured in the great film The Life Aquatic with Steve Zissou, where a man from time to time plays acoustic covers of classic David Bowie-songs translated to Portuguese (wow, that is a strange sentence). All of the interpretations are beautiful, but this one is just outstanding.)
- Flesh Failures - Lightspeed Champion (Unfortunately, I couldn't find this song on Youtube, but I deeply recommend you to find it and listen to it (I believe it's on Spotify). Lightspeed Champion is one of my absolute favourite artists who released his debut album Falling off the lavender bridge last year. He was also a member of epic punk/metal/indie/rap/electro/whatever/rock-band Test Icicles, which makes this cover so cool. This hyped artist who's been on the cover of NME and who's been a guest on Never mind the buzzcocks (hilarious episode) decides to cover a song from the musical Hair. Flabbergasting.)
- Hey Joe - Nick Cave & The Bad Seeds (Darn it! Why can't I find the songs I want to share? Anyway, this is also a really good and very original cover of the classic American song Hey Joe, made famous by Jimi Hendrix (he just comes back round again and again) and his bnad in the 1960's. The song is now a rock standard, but what Nick Cave does with it unbelievable. Find it. Hear it.)
- Redemption song - Johnny Cash and Joe Strummer (This song is originally written by Bob Marley, who in my opinion is one of the most overrated artists of all time. I really don't like the original version of this song, but when Johnny Cash sings this song, accompanied by Joe Strummer from The Clash, it sounds like the last words of a broken man, which fits perfect.)
- The man who sold the world - Nirvana (Another Bowie song. I'm not a big fan of Nirvana. Sure, they've done some really good songs, but in general I would call them at most average. But there is one exception, and that is the live album Unplugged. The sound is really smooth and the voice of Kurt Cobain is as harsh as it ever was. The whole record is very, very good, but the cover of The man who sold the world is pure perfection.)
I hope this helped you sorting things out.